Small sites, big losses: The BNG exemption is the strongest argument yet for a national tree replacement standard.

Since 6 August this year, the smallest developments in England (those 0.2 hectares or smaller) no longer have to deliver biodiversity net gain (BNG). To understand what this means for trees, we’ve analysed 505 biodiversity gain plans and 320 readable metric calculations gathered from 59 planning authorities.

The answer is uncomfortable: the exemption removes roughly half of all development sites from the BNG regime, and these are precisely the sites on which trees make up the largest share of the habitat being lost.

In December 2023 we argued for a new Bristol Tree Replacement Standard (BTRS) calibrated to the statutory biodiversity metric. That argument was about making the local standard consistent with national policy. It’s now about something much more critical: on half of all sites, a local standard is the only thing left to protect trees being lost to development.


What changed on 6 August 2026

The Biodiversity Gain (Town and Country Planning) (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) (England) Regulations 2026 (SI 2026/790) took effect for planning applications made on or after 6 August 2026. The three changes made matter here:

  1. A site of 0.2 hectares or less, measured by the red-line boundary of the application, is exempt from mandatory BNG unless on-site priority habitat is negatively affected.
  2. Development that’s wholly temporary, with permission granted for five years or less, is also exempt on the same proviso.
  3. For minor development above the area threshold, the mitigation hierarchy has been relaxed: off-site gains are now seen as just as desirable as created or enhanced habitat on the site itself, so a developer may go straight off site without first showing that on-site provision is unachievable.

The self-build and custom-build exemption has also been removed, on the reasoning that most such schemes now fall inside the new small-sites exemption anyway. While applications already submitted before 6 August continue under the old rules, Defra in its 15 April 2026 response to the consultation, estimated that ‘the new area based exemption for sites of less than 0.2 hectares is expected to remove more than 50% of the smallest planning applications which are currently delivering mandatory BNG, from the BNG requirement’.


Trees aren’t priority habitat

The priority habitat proviso sounds protective, and for some sites it is, but it does nothing for trees. Depending on where it is, an individual tree is recorded in the statutory metric as urban tree or rural tree, both of medium distinctiveness; neither is a habitat of principal importance under section 41 of the Natural Environment and Rural Communities Act 2006. Only ancient and veteran trees sit outside these two categories, as irreplaceable habitat, and they are a vanishingly small proportion of the trees felled for development.

So a mature street-side lime, a garden oak, or a row of maturing London planes on the edge of a school playing field — none of these will be protected if they’re in the way of a 0.2 hectare development. Below the threshold, they can be removed without any obligation to count them, replace them, or compensate for their loss anywhere. Unless the tree is protected by a Tree Preservation Order, or unless the local plan says otherwise, nothing now requires their loss to be made good.

This is the gap; and it’s much larger than the word ‘small’ implies.


Half of all development sites now fall outside the system

We measured site area for every gain plan in our dataset that came with a usable metric calculation — 305 sites across 59 authorities. Site area here is the baseline area-habitat total, net of any individual trees, taken from the statutory metric or, for small-sites metrics.

Table 1. Development sites by size, 305 sites with a usable metric calculation
Site size Sites Share Baseline area HUs Post-development area HUs On-site change
0.2 ha or smaller 151 49.5% 48.79 48.67 −0.25%
Over 0.2 ha 154 50.5% 506.88 512.82 +1.17%
All sites 305 100% 555.67 561.49 +1.05%

Habitat units are on-site figures from sections 6.3 and 6.4 of the biodiversity gain plan. Hedgerows and watercourses are excluded as linear features.

Just under half of the sites that have been going through the BNG process fall at or below the new exemption threshold — consistent with Defra’s own estimate. Two further things stand out in that table. First, small sites were barely holding their own on site even under the old regime that’s just been withdrawn: a baseline of 48.79 area habitat units became a mere 48.67 after development, a small net loss, with any gain bought off site from elsewhere. Second, the small-site total is dwarfed by the large-site total, which is exactly why the exemption looked politically cheap. In habitat unit terms these sites are a rounding error. In tree terms, though, they aren’t.


Small sites are where the trees are

Of the 320 metric calculations we could read, 163 relate to sites of 0.2 hectares or less. Sixty of these — 36.8% — record individual trees in the on-site baseline. Between them they carry 3.12 hectares of tree canopy ‘oversailing’ 15.22 hectares of land.

Table 2. Individual trees in the on-site baseline, by site size
Site size Metrics With trees Site area (ha) Canopy (ha) Canopy as % of site area Tree baseline HUs
0.2 ha or less 163 60 (36.8%) 15.22 3.12 20.5% 26.71
Over 0.2 ha 157 81 (51.6%) 219.64 13.79 6.3% 133.22
All sites 320 141 (44.1%) 234.85 16.91 7.2% 159.94

Site area is net of individual trees, because tree canopy oversails the habitat beneath it and is not additional land. Canopy can therefore exceed 100% of the site area it overlies.

That last comparison is the heart of it. On sites above the threshold, tree canopy is equivalent to about 6% of the site area. On sites at or below 0.2 hectares it’s 20.5% — more than three times the share. Small sites are disproportionately tree rich, probably because they’re disproportionately urban: they include infill plots, back gardens, corners of school and hospital grounds, and the fringes of existing built-up land. These are the places where we usually find the mature tree canopy of a town.

The concentration is sharper still for twenty of the 163 small-site metrics, which record canopy covering more than half the site area. Seven record canopy exceeding the whole of it. One example is a 0.18 hectare site at 22 York Road in Sutton, which carries 0.33 hectares of canopy across 18 recorded tree entries — canopy equal to 182% of the site, and worth 3.42 habitat units. At an average of 0.019 hectares of canopy each, these are mature trees, not saplings — on the replacement standard set out below, losing 18 medium trees would require 90 replacements. On an application made today, that site would be exempt and the trees could be removed without any obligation to replace them under the new BNG regime.

Expressed as trees rather than hectares, the 3.12 hectares of canopy on small sites is equivalent to 762 small trees, using the 0.0041 hectares the June 2026 metric assigns to a small tree. Because much of that canopy belongs to medium, large and very large trees, the actual number of trees is likely to be lower — and their replacement cost, in the metric’s own currency, correspondingly higher.


And they’re where the new trees were coming from

The exemption removes an obligation to plant as well as an obligation to compensate. Of the 163 small-site metrics, 72 record individual trees created as part of the post-development scheme.

Table 3. Individual trees created in post-development proposals
Site size Metrics With tree creation On-site trees Off-site trees Total trees
0.2 ha or smaller 163 72 (44.2%) 597 8 605
Over 0.2 ha 157 97 (61.8%) 3,135 205 3,340
All sites 320 169 (52.8%) 3,731 213 3,944

Tree numbers are the recorded habitat creation area divided by 0.0041 ha per small tree, rounded up. Off-site units bought from a registered gain site do not appear here, because they sit in the seller’s metric.

Over 600 trees across a dataset of a few hundred plans covering barely two years and 59 authorities out of 306. If you scale that across every planning authority in England and across the years ahead, the tree planting foregone is substantial.


BNG was never going to save urban trees anyway

It’s worth being clear that the case for a local tree standard doesn’t rest solely on the exemption. Even where BNG still applies, it often doesn’t keep compensation anywhere near the trees that were lost.

The Biodiversity Gain Sites register as of 19 August 2026 — 2,328 developments across 306 authorities — shows that 87% of developments in urban authorities offset outside their own authority area. Those authorities needed 1,835 area habitat units and hosted 889. In London the pattern is near total: 98% of the 113 registered London borough developments offset elsewhere, requiring 46.8 units and hosting 3.3.

The units are real, and the receiving sites may well be excellent. But a habitat unit delivered in a rural county doesn’t provide shade in Bristol, intercept its rainfall, cool it in a heatwave, or stand outside anybody’s window. Urban tree canopy is a local public good, yet BNG systematically moves its replacement to some distant field that few, if any, will ever visit.


Why we need a tree replacement standard

A tree replacement standard is a local plan policy, not a national biodiversity calculation. It attaches to the tree, not to the site area; it applies whether or not a metric has to be completed; and it keeps the replacement in or close to the place where the loss occurred. It’s the mechanism best suited to fill the gap the exemption has opened.

This is not a novel invention. Bristol has operated the BTRS since 2014 under Core Strategy policy BCS9, and a replacement table is carried forward into proposed local plan policy BG4. What we argued in 2023 was that the ratios should be recalibrated so that the standard delivers what the statutory metric would have delivered, plus the 10% uplift. Our proposal was not adopted then, though our argument stands. What’s changed is who needs it: not just Bristol, but every planning authority that wants any control at all over tree loss on the majority of its planning applications.

We would encourage authorities without such a policy to adopt one, and those with one to check that it’s calibrated to the metric rather than to a historic rule of thumb whose rationale was and remains hard to understand. As the standard is a local plan policy, it can be applied to exempt sites without cutting across the national BNG regime: BNG sets a floor for biodiversity, and a replacement standard sets a separate, local requirement for canopy.


Recalculating the standard against the June 2026 metric

Our 2023 proposal derived replacement numbers from the tree area equivalents then in force. Those figures have since changed. Table 15 of the Statutory Biodiversity Metric User Guide (June 2026), at page 62, now assigns the areas set out below. Applying the same method — the area of the lost tree divided by the area of one small tree, since a newly planted tree is recorded as small, plus the 10% net gain, rounded up because a fraction of a tree is not a tree — gives revised numbers.

Table 4. Replacement trees required, recalculated against the June 2026 metric
Tree size (DBH) Area equivalent (ha) Multiple of a small tree Plus 10% net gain Replacement trees 2023 proposal
Small (>7.5–30 cm) 0.0041 1.00 1.10 2 1
Medium (>30–60 cm) 0.0163 3.98 4.37 5 3
Large (>60–90 cm) 0.0366 8.93 9.82 10 10
Very large (>90 cm) 0.0765 18.66 20.52 21 20

Areas are from Table 15 of the Statutory Biodiversity Metric User Guide (June 2026), p62. Replacement numbers are the tree’s area divided by the area of one small tree, plus the 10% net gain, rounded up.

Two categories of tree size move. A medium tree is now worth almost four small trees rather than three, so its replacement requirement rises from three to five. A very large tree rises from 20 to 21. Large trees are unchanged at ten.

The small-tree row needs a decision rather than an arithmetic answer. One small tree replaced by 1.1 small trees rounds up to two, which is a real doubling for the commonest category in the surveyed population. The alternative is to hold the small category at one-for-one and take the 10% uplift from the scheme as a whole. We think the honest position is to state the arithmetic and let the policy make the choice explicitly, rather than round the uplift away in silence.


What we’re asking for

  • That local planning authorities adopt, or retain and strengthen, a tree replacement standard in their local plan, applying to all development including sites exempt from mandatory BNG.
  • That the replacement ratios be calibrated to the current tree area equivalents in the statutory metric, so that a local standard delivers no less than the national regime would have done.
  • That replacement be required within the same authority area and as close to the loss site as is practicable, so that canopy is replaced where people live.
  • That authorities continue to require a BS 5837:2012 tree survey with applications on exempt sites, so that the loss is properly recorded even where no metric is required.
  • That Defra keep the 0.2 hectare exemption under review, and specifically consider whether the priority habitat proviso should be extended to sites carrying significant tree canopy.

The exemption was introduced to reduce costs and delays for small applications. Whatever one makes of that aim, it shouldn’t be paid for with the mature canopy of our towns and cities. A tree replacement standard is a cheap, well-understood, locally enforceable way of making sure it’s not.


About the data

Figures are drawn from the Bristol Tree Forum biodiversity gain plan dataset (v11): 505 gain plans logged from 59 planning authorities, of which 320 carry a readable statutory or small-sites metric calculation and 305 a usable site area. Plans are dated 2024 (58), 2025 (254) and 2026 (165). Register figures are from the Biodiversity Gain Sites register extract of 19 August 2026, covering 2,328 developments and 2,686 allocations across 306 authorities.

Two caveats:

  1. Site area in this analysis is the metric’s baseline habitat area net of individual trees, which is a close proxy for the red-line boundary the exemption uses but not identical to it; a handful of sites near the threshold may fall on the other side of it in practice.
  2. The sample is of applications that produced a gain plan, so it describes the population the exemption removes rather than all development across the country.

Take a look at our recent follow-up which looks at the immediate impact of this new exemption for Bristol :

Looking at Bristol’s development sites

Biodiversity gain: will urban nature become hollowed out?

In a boost for the environment, new legislation now obliges most developers to set out how they will achieve at least 10% more biodiversity than already exists on their proposed development sites.

Developers must now show how they will improve the biodiversity of their development site as a result of their works. Developers must record the (baseline) on-site habitats that exist before development starts and show how they will either enhance or replace these on site. If their proposals fail to reach the 10% threshold, the developer may provide the shortfall elsewhere. This post-development mitigation should be done as closely as possible to the development site, or at least within the Local Authority. However, if this isn’t possible, they can use approved sites anywhere in England.

This approach is called the Biodiversity Gain Hierarchy (found in Schedule 7A of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 at section 37A). The Hierarchy says it’s a priority to avoid the ‘adverse effects’ to ‘onsite habitat with a habitat distinctiveness score … equal to or higher than four.’ If this can’t be avoided, only then is mitigation permitted. In our experience, nearly all developers ignore the requirement to avoid adverse effects and move straight on to mitigation.

Since the introduction of the Bristol Tree Replacement Standard in 2013, developers (and planners) have ignored the policy requirement to avoid tree removal where at all possible. Instead, they’ve moved straight on to providing compensation for the trees lost to the development. As a result, the money set aside for replacement tree planting was not spent (on occasion reaching nearly £1 million) and many of the lost trees were never replaced.

Under the Hierarchy, habitats that score four are designated as having medium distinctiveness. While many habitats have medium distinctiveness, many don’t. For example, managed grassed areas (called ‘modified grassland’) are often found on urban sites but have a low distinctiveness score. So, too, do many other urban habitats such as allotments and gardens. Developers are not required to avoid harming these, though losses to these habitats must still be mitigated.

There’s no definition of what an ‘adverse effect’ is or any guidance on how it is assessed. However, recent advice from the Bristol’s Chief Planner about the meaning of ‘harm’ suggests that this could be interpreted very broadly or simply ignored because some sort of mitigation will always be available.

In the last extreme, developers may purchase biodiversity credits. We wait to see how this and the offsite biodiversity mitigation market evolves, but a 2012 paper published in the Harvard Environmental Law Review suggests that such environmental markets are prisoners of their own geography because the space available is always constrained:

Markets for water quality, biodiversity, endangered species, fisheries, air quality, and aquatic resources, to name a few, must recognize that the commodities they trade exist at particular geographic scales, and set appropriate spatial limits on the redistribution of environmental quality. The size of geographic trading areas has significant implications for the economic viability of markets and the ecological quality of their offsets.

This will be a particular challenge when providing biodiversity mitigation in urban areas.

The squeeze on green spaces

Land use in Bristol is subject to intense competition by many stakeholders. This is especially true for our green and open spaces, which offer many ‘services’ beyond just habitat provision. There is very little, if any, space available for new biodiversity to be created. At best, some green spaces might be enhanced, but opportunities to do this are likely to be very limited.

For example, Bristol Tree Forum’s examination of the three proposals to develop Bedminster Green shows that, if these proposals are allowed, then nearly 400 new trees will need to be planted to compensate for the lost tree habitat – a medium distinctiveness habitat. There’s no room to plant these trees on site, so offsite provision will be needed. There are very few opportunities for doing any new tree planting (as opposed to replacing lost trees) in the surrounding wards or even across Bristol, let alone, as is usually required, within a mile of a development site.

Instead, these replacement trees will have to be planted somewhere else: ‘in some foreign field that is forever Bristol’. This will inevitably lead to a net loss of biodiversity across the city as nature is ‘hollowed out’. This is unacceptable. The whole purpose of the new biodiversity gain regime is to improve overall local biodiversity, but it seems inevitable that Bristol will instead see a steady, inexorable decline.

We are disappointed that the current draft of the new Local Plan addresses none of these issues and have said so in our responses to the latest consultation:

Bristol Tree Forum representations in relation to the Bristol Local Plan 2023 Publication Version consultation & BTF Representations on the Bristol Local Plan 2023 publication version – Addendum.


A shorter version of this article was published by 24/7 as:

‘It seems inevitable Bristol will see a steady, inexorable biodiversity decline’


The trading rules explained

Much has been made of the new rules that require most developments to add at least 10% more biodiversity to a site than was present before development took place. This requirement is known as biodiversity net gain (BNG).

However, a much-overlooked aspect of the new rules is the requirement also to comply with so-called trading rules.

These trading rules set minimum requirements for habitat creation and enhancement to compensate for specific habitat losses resulting from a new development.

If these rules are not followed, a developer cannot claim that there is biodiversity net gain, even if the planning application has achieved the minimum 10% BNG required. 

Rule 1 of the Statutory Metric and the Small Sites Metric (SSM) guides state that the trading rules must be followed.

Rule 2 states that biodiversity unit outputs for each habitat type – Area, Hedgerow or Watercourse – must not be added together, traded, or converted between types. The requirement to deliver at least a 10% net gain applies to each separate habitat type. 

The trading rules only apply to the point of no net loss of a specific habitat. Once the trading rules have been met for this habitat, the biodiversity net gain requirements can be met by the creation and enhancement of any other habitat, provided it is the same habitat type. 

This table from the Statutory Metric sets out how they apply:

The trading rules for the SSM are slightly different. This is because the SSM does not cater for high and very high distinctiveness habitats (if these are present, the Statutory Metric must be used):

Although the calculator warns of any breaches of the trading rules, the design of the SSM does not allow users to identify where the breaches have occurred. However, the Statutory Metric does. So, if the habitats input into the SSM calculator are transposed to the Statutory Metric calculator, this will reveal where the trading rules breaches are and allow the user to consider how to mitigate the losses whilst still complying with the trading rules.

There are special rules for very high distinctiveness habitats and for compensating for loss of watercourses and high distinctiveness woodland, which are not addressed here.


How the trading rules apply to urban tree habitats

Individual trees habitat has medium distinctiveness. This means that this habitat can only be replaced like for like, although higher distinctiveness habitats can be substituted when the Statutory Metric is used.

Other broad habitats with the same distinctiveness cannot be substituted. For example, Woodland and forest habitat cannot be used to replace lost Individual trees habitat unless it has a higher distinctiveness and the SSM is not being used.

As a result, the requirement to replace lost trees can result in many more trees having to be planted (often off site) than will be lost. In one recent example we examined, 116 replacement trees were needed to comply with the trading rules, even though only 12 were being removed.

Hopefully, developers will now think twice before seeking to remove trees to make way for their plans.



Other Blogs in the series

Calculating habitat units

Tree habitat area calculation


Calculating tree habitat area

A key factor in calculating the value of a habitat under the new Statutory Biodiversity Metric is to work out its size. In the case of trees, their habitat size can be of critical importance to the calculation of their biodiversity valuation which will, in turn, help to preserve our precious tree habitats.

As a result, individual trees in an urban setting are often the most important habitat present.

Unfortunately, developers may be tempted to allocate all trees on their planned development site (especially those in groups) to Woodland and forest habitats rather than to Individual trees habitat, because this gives the trees and the site a lower biodiversity value. An example of this is the proposed development by Goram Homes of Hengrove Park in Bristol, as shown in the image above and discussed below. The whole site was granted outline planning permission in October 2019.

Unfortunately, the Statutory Biodiversity Metric User Guide (the Metric) definitions of these habitats are ambiguous and can make such allocations hard to counter, even in settings that are clearly urban.

The User Guide defines two broad tree habitats types whose areas are measured in hectares (ha):

  • Woodland and forest
  • Individual trees

Defining woodland and forest habitat

There are conflicting definitions of ‘woodland’. The Metric User Guide does not define Woodland and forest habitat.

However, the UK Habitat Classification, UKHab, upon which the Metric is based, defines it as ‘Land with 25% or more cover of trees that are five metres or more in height.’ This definition doesn’t mention the minimum land area required.

The UK National Forest Inventory 2015 (NFI) defines woodland as:

‘a minimum area of 0.5 hectares under stands of trees with, or with the potential to achieve, tree crown cover of more than 20% of the ground. Areas of young trees, which have the potential to achieve a canopy cover of more than 20%, will also be interpreted as woodland and mapped. The minimum width for woodland is 20 m, although where woodlands are connected by a narrow neck of woodland less than 20 m wide, the break may be disregarded if less than 20 m in extent.‘

Bristol City Council also uses area to define woodland in its 2008 Biodiversity Action Plan (Chapter 5, page 65), which states that ‘this action plan covers all woodlands over 0.5 hectares in extent found in Bristol.‘ As this is a local policy, and aligned with the NFI definition, we have adopted it.

The habitat area of Woodland and forest habitats is based on its total measured canopy area.

Defining individual trees habitat

The Metric User Guide (page 53) advises when to record Individual trees habitat:

Individual trees are classed as ‘urban’ or ‘rural’. You should consider the degree of ‘urbanisation’ of habitats around the tree and assign the best fit for the location. 

Use the broad habitat type ‘Individual trees’ to record: 

  • individual rural trees 
  • individual urban trees 
  • lines, blocks or groups of trees found within and around the perimeter of urban land.

In all circumstances ‘Individual trees’ should be used to record ancient and veteran trees, regardless of location. This could include ancient and veteran trees within hedgerows, ‘rural’ lines of trees and woodlands. 

Other clarifications

Do not use the hedgerow module classifications ‘line of trees’ and ‘ecologically valuable line of trees’ to record linear formations of trees in the urban environment.

These classifications should only be used for rural lines of trees.
Trees within overgrown non-native and ornamental hedges (for example, leylandii) should not be classified as individual trees, or as lines of trees. Record these as nonnative ornamental hedges within the hedgerow module.

Trees recorded as individual trees that will be removed for any purpose, including development, disease, or safety must be recorded in your baseline and recorded as lost.

Do not otherwise record individual trees if they occur within a habitat type characterised by the presence of trees, unless specified within the section on ‘recording individual trees at baseline’, which covers: 

  • trees within private gardens 
  • removal of trees within hedgerows 
  • removal of trees within rural lines of trees 
  • removal of trees within orchards and wood-pasture and parkland 

Recording individual trees at baseline 

The biodiversity metric uses set values to represent the area of individual trees depending on their diameter at breast height. 

This value is a representation of canopy biomass, and is based on the root protection area formula, derived from BS 5837:2012. 

Table 14 sets out class sizes of trees and their area equivalent. 

The User Guide then deals with specific instances where individual tree habitats also need to be recorded:

Recording baseline trees within private gardens

A private garden is a garden within the curtilage of a privately owned or tenanted dwelling house. Private gardens can contain important features for biodiversity, including mature trees and hedgerows. 

record all medium, large and very large trees within private gardens as individual trees 

Recording baseline trees within hedgerows and lines of trees 

  • if any medium, large or very large trees within a hedgerow or ‘rural’ line of trees are being removed, record these in the area baseline as individual trees 
  • the removal of trees may influence the linear value of hedgerows and ‘rural’ lines of trees within the hedgerow module 

Recording baseline trees within orchards and wood-pasture and parkland 

  • if any medium, large and very large trees within these habitats are being removed, record these in the area baseline as individual trees 
  • this does not change the way in which you would record the area of orchard or wood-pasture and parkland area habitat (see ‘Recording habitat mosaics’ section) 

Calculating the number of post-development trees required

Post-development size classes 

When planting trees post-development size class is determined by the size of the tree at site-planting. When using the tree helper: 

  • record newly planted individual trees as ‘small’, unless ‘medium’ size or above at the time of site-planting 
  • record trees planted with a DBH less than 7.5 cm as ‘small’ 

You should not: 

  • record natural size increases of retained trees within post-development sheets 
  • record natural size increases of planted trees within post-development sheets 

The post-development private garden has no public access, and biodiversity net gains cannot be legally secured. As these gains cannot be secured you should only record created private gardens as either: 

  • ‘urban – vegetated garden’; or 
  • ‘urban – unvegetated garden’ 

You should not: 

  • record the creation of any other new habitats within private gardens 
  • record enhancement of any habitat within private gardens 

However, habitats which are recorded in the baseline and remain within a private garden may be recorded as retained. 

A garden within the curtilage of a privately owned or tenanted dwelling house.  The post-development private garden has no public access, and biodiversity net gains cannot be legally secured. 

How these rules affect the tree habitat area calculation

As a result, this approach places a higher value on the areas of all but the largest Individual trees habitats than those that form part of a Woodland and forest habitat. The following graph shows this, with RPA, derived from DBH, representing the canopy biomass of both broad habitats.

We analysed 12 recent planning applications involving 2,116 trees, 612 (29%) of which were identified for removal. Using the Metric User Guide, they have a combined habitat area of 20.2 ha. If they are measured by canopy area it would only be 8.3 ha (41% of their habitat size). If their combined Root Protection Areas (RPA) were used, they would cover only 8.6 ha (43% of their habitat size).

On the basis that all these trees are in poor condition and have no strategic significance, we calculate that, with the minimum 10% biodiversity net gain now required, a total of 1,925 new trees would need to be planted to replace the habitat lost by the removal of these 612 tree – a ratio of just over 3:1.

To illustrate how this can affect actual applications, here’s a pending application by Goram Homes at Hengrove Park in Bristol. The area edged in red is the development site.

This next image shows how the applicant’s ecologists have defined each habitat: the woodland and forest habitats are shown as a diamond pattern on a dark green background. They cover 2.44 ha.

They’ve also identified 0.19 ha of Individual trees habitat, that is, trees not growing within the woodland and forest habitats.

Area 8 in the south of the site (0.99 ha) might legitimately be designated Woodland and forest habitat, but, given that all the remaining trees are growing separately and in groups in an urban park, they should be designated Urban Individual tree habitat.

The site is complex, with many trees growing in groups but, by excluding the trees in area 8 and treating all the other onsite trees as Urban Individual tree habitat, we calculate that their habitat area is 6.42 ha. This is 4.78 ha more than the applicant’s calculation. This difference will clearly have a significant impact on the final biodiversity net gain calculation, valuing these habitats at 34.07 area habitat units (or 2,989 Small size trees) as opposed to the applicant’s 12.11 (or 1,063 Small size trees).

To give the applicant their due, they at least attempted to calculate the tree habitat area. We have seen other applications where the trees were simply ignored, or were classified as another habitat – bramble scrub in one case, or the method by which the Individual trees habitat area was calculated bore no relationship to the evidence submitted. We must remain ever vigilant against such tricks.


This blog was amended on 09 May 2024 to include the comments of the Nature Conservation Officer dated 03 May 2024 about whether the trees on the Hengrove Park development site are Individual trees habitat or Woodland and forest habitat. The officer writes:

This blog was amended on 14 February 2024 following the obligation for most planning applications to achieve at least 10% biodiversity gain becoming obligatory on 12 February 2024.

Further changes have been made following updates published in July and August 2024, in particular the clarification of the application of BNG in private gardens.


Other Blogs in the series

Calculating habitat units

The trading rules explained


Why we need a new Bristol Tree Replacement Standard

We believe the time has come to revise the Bristol Tree Replacement Standard (BTRS), to reflect our changing understanding of the vital importance of urban trees to Bristol and how they contribute to biodiversity gain.

The current BTRS Standard, adopted nearly a decade ago in July 2014, provides a mechanism for calculating the number of replacements needed for any trees that are removed for developments. It was ground-breaking in its time as it, typically, required more than 1:1 replacement of trees lost to development.

Since then, Defra has published the statutory version of the Biodiversity Metric (SM) (on 29 November 2023), which became mandatory on 12 February 2024. In addition, Bristol has adopted Climate and Ecological Emergency Declarations, so an updated BTRS would be an important part of implementing these declarations. It would require all new developments, subject to some exceptions, to achieve a Biodiversity Net Gain (BNG) of at least 10%. Where developments are exempt, BTRS will still apply.

Although Councillors rejected our proposals for a new Standard at their meeting on 31 October last, we’ve revisited our July 2023 proposals and recast our calculations. These proposals, set out below, provide a mechanism for complying with the new requirements and align the BTRS with the BNG provisions of the EA 2021.

The purpose of the BTRS is that it should only ever be a last resort and not the default choice – which, unfortunately, it has become. When considering any development involving established trees, the presumption should always be that trees will be retained. If this is not possible, then the impact of the proposed development must be mitigated. Only if this is impossible, should compensation for their loss be considered. This is the meaning of the Mitigation Hierarchy, as set out in paragraph 180 a) of the National Planning Policy Framework, which states:

If significant harm to biodiversity resulting from a development cannot be avoided (through locating on an alternative site with less harmful impacts), adequately mitigated, or, as a last resort, compensated for, then planning permission should be refused.

This is reflected in the Bristol Core Strategy, policy BCS9 (page 29),which states that:

Individual green assets should be retained wherever possible and integrated into new developments.

This is repeated in the proposed replacement for BCS9 – Policy BG1: Green infrastructure and biodiversity in new development (page 124) – which ‘aims to ensure that green and blue infrastructure and provision for nature is incorporated into new development’ so that, among other things:

The provision of green infrastructure in new development should … Retain and incorporate important existing green infrastructure such as trees (Policy BG4 ‘Trees’), hedgerows and water features …

It is a shame that the requirement is only an aspiration, not an obligation.

Background

Under the new proposed policy – BG4: Trees (page 131) – trees lost to development will be replaced using this table:

Table 1 The proposed BG4 tree replacement table.

However, when the balance of EA 2021 takes effect, the current version of the BTRS will not, in most cases, be enough to achieve the 10% BNG minimum required for nearly all developments. A new Section 90A and Schedule 7A will be added to the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 and will set out the level of BNG required.

Paragraph: 001 Reference ID: 74-001-20240214 of the Biodiversity net gain guidance states:

Under the statutory framework for biodiversity net gain, subject to some exceptions, every grant of planning permission is deemed to have been granted subject to the condition that the biodiversity gain objective is met (“the biodiversity gain condition”). This objective is for development to deliver at least a 10% increase in biodiversity value relative to the pre-development biodiversity value of the onsite habitat. …

Many development proposals will aim to achieve more than the minimum 10% gain voluntarily. Others may not but will still need to achieve much more in order to comply with the SM trading rules (page 140). This is based on the habitat type lost and its distinctiveness. In the case of Individual tree habitats – Urban or Rural –­ losses must be replaced within the same broad habitat (i.e. more Individual trees) or with a habitat of a higher distinctiveness.

However, for the sake of certainty, we propose only using the minimum 10% BNG required.

Our proposed new BG4 (BTRS) model

We propose that the table in BG4 be amended to reflect the requirements of the EA 2021 and SM and that the BG4 table (Table 1 above) be replaced with Table 2 below:

Table 2 Our proposed BG4 tree replacement requirement

The Replacement Trees Required number is based on the habitat area of each of the four SM tree category sizes (Table 13 below), divided by the area habitat of one BNG 4.0 Small category tree (see section 3 below) plus a 10% net gain. This is rounded up to the nearest whole number (since you can’t plant a fraction of a tree).

The reasoning for our proposal is set out below:

1. Applying the Biodiversity Metric to Urban trees

The most recent Statutory Biodiversity Metric User Guide defines trees as Individual trees habitats as follows:

When to record individual trees

Use the broad habitat type ‘Individual trees’ to record trees where:

  • they are found as an individual or as part of a group;
  • are over 7.5cm in diameter at breast height (DBH).

Individual trees should also be recorded where they meet the definition of an irreplaceable habitat but would not otherwise be recorded.

Do not otherwise record individual trees if they occur within an area habitat type characterised by the presence of trees, examples of these are:

  • woodlands
  • orchards
  • wood-pasture and parkland

Individual trees are classed as ‘urban’ or ‘rural’. You should consider the degree of ‘urbanisation’ of habitats around the tree and assign the best fit for the location.

2. Calculating Individual trees habitat

Table 13 in the SM User Guide is used to calculate the ‘area equivalent’ of individual trees:

The biodiversity metric uses set values to represent the area of trees depending on their diameter at breast height. This value is a representation of canopy biomass, and is based on the root protection area formula, derived from BS 5837:2012.

You should report the number of individual trees within your project and input tree count into the ‘tree helper’ within the biodiversity metric tool to generate area values for data input. For multi-stemmed trees, use the DBH of the largest stem. You should:

  • account for each individual tree within a group or block of trees.
  • record the habitat underneath the tree canopy separately.
  • not reduce any area generated by the tree helper.
  • not deduct the area of individual trees from other habitats.
  • make clear in the user comments how many trees contribute towards the total area.

Recording trees within private gardens

You should assess most individual trees that are recorded in private gardens. You should record:

  • any medium, large and very large trees as individual trees
  • any small trees that are ancient or veteran

Recording trees within hedgerows

You should assess most individual trees that are recorded within hedgerows. You should record:

  • any medium, large and very large trees as individual trees
  • any small trees unless they are ancient or veteran.

You must assess the linear value of hedgerows within the hedgerow module separately.

Individual Tree habitats have medium distinctiveness and so, under Rule 1 of SBNG, ‘Losses must be replaced by area habitat units of either medium band habitats within the same broad habitat type or, any habitat from a higher band from any broad habitat type.’

3. Forecasting the post-development area of Individual trees

The SBNG User Guide provides this guidance:

You should use the tree helper to calculate the area for created trees.

You should categorise most newly planted individual trees as ‘small’, unless the tree is medium sized or above at the time of planting.

You should not factor in the age of nursery stock when using the ‘creation in advance’ function. The ‘creation in advance’ function should only be used where trees are planted in advance of the development (for example, as screening or as structural landscaping).

Exceptions

You cannot count:

  • newly planted trees within private gardens
  • natural size increases of baseline trees
  • trees planted as part of hedgerow creation or enhancement as individual trees.

Our calculations are based on Small category replacement trees being planted as per the SM guidance.

4. The likely impact of this policy change

We have analysed tree data for 1,038 surveyed trees taken from a sample of BS:5837 2012 tree surveys submitted in support of previous planning applications. Most of the trees in this sample, 60.5%, fall within the SM Small tree category, 32.9% are within the Medium tree category, 5.4% are in the Large tree category with the balance, 1.3%, being categorised as Very Large.

Table 4 below sets out the likely impact of the proposed changes to BG4. It assumes that all these trees were removed (though that was not the case for all the planning applications we sampled) and replaced with SM Small category trees:

Table 4 Proposed BG4 impact analysis.

The spreadsheet setting out the basis of our calculations can be downloaded here – RPA Table Statutory BNG 13 table Comparison.

The proposed Local Plan is not yet ready for further consultation let alone independent examination – an Open Letter to Councillors

Dear Councillors

The Mayor has now published the next iteration of the proposed new Local Plan (LP). This will be brought before you at Full Council on 31 October next. The Mayor recommends (item 8) that, under Regulation 19 of the Town and Country Planning (Local Planning) (England) Regulations 2012, the draft LP will be formally published in order for representations to be made and then submitted to the Secretary of State for examination.

The sustainability appraisal documents are published on the Local Plan Review web page.

In our opinion the proposed LP is not yet ready for further consultation, let alone independent examination, for the following reasons:

  1. It does not contain enough detailed information about the sites in the adopted LP to allow for a proper consultation or independent examination.
  2. Protection for green spaces has been reduced, contrary to adopted Council policy. 
  3. Despite the recent Ecological and Climate Emergency Declarations, this draft provides fewer environmental protections than the adopted LP.
  4. Comments on earlier drafts appear largely to have been ignored, rendering the consultation process flawed.

Our response in detail

Section 20 (2) of the Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act 2004 states that the authority must not submit the proposed LP unless they think the document is ready for independent examination. In our view, the proposed LP is not yet ready for further consultation, let alone independent examination. Our reasons are set out in detail below:

A proper consultation has not been conducted. In a 2001 judgement Lord Woolf defined a proper consultation as containing four elements.[1] The final element is that ‘the product of consultation must be conscientiously taken into account when the ultimate decision is taken’. You have not responded to our carefully considered comments on both the 2019 and the 2022 consultations on earlier drafts of the LP and there is no evidence that the Local Plan Working Party even discussed them. We do not know how many other organisations who submitted comments were also ignored, because these have not been published.

  1. When the 2019 document, New Protection for Open Space, was published for consultation, a schedule with maps was produced so that consultees could see which sites were being proposed and with what designation – Local Green Space (LGS) or Reserved Open Space (ROS). No such document has been produced in this version, which means that there is no easy way for consultees to see what has been changed, added or removed – save for slavishly working though the only document showing the new designations set out in 08.3 Appendix A3 Policies Map. Whilst this may be sufficient for those interested only in the information at ward level, it is nigh on impossible for those with a city-wide interest.
  2. An interactive GIS map of the proposed Bristol Local Plan Policies Map should be made available to facilitate examination. The pdf version provided has 38 layers in the Key and many sites have multiple designations, which makes it very difficult to interpret. The current Local Plan Policies map does this.
  3. Whilst the document Appendix 3 Assessing the effects of the Publication Version Policies, cross-references, to a limited extent, how some proposed new policies relate to policies in the adopted LP, there is no equivalent schedule for the adopted policies which will be removed – Core, Site Allocation and Development Management Policies (SADMP) and ancillary Supplementary Planning Documents (SPDs) etc. – nor any comprehensive cross-tabulation showing which of the adopted LP policies have been transferred to the proposed LP and which have not.
  4. No schedule has been prepared showing those sites protected under the adopted LP and whether they will be protected under the proposed LP. For example, SADMP DM17 currently provides protection for sites designated as Important Open Spaces, Unidentified Open Spaces and Urban landscapes. It appears that DM17 will be removed but that these current protections will not be adopted in the proposed LP. We have mapped 523 Important Open Space sites covering over 2,000 hectares. As far as we can see, some 1,000 hectares of these and all Unidentified Open Spaces and Urban landscapes, will no longer have any protection. If this is the case, then the proposals should make this clear. Our recent article, Will Councillors Honour Their Promise To Protect Bristol’s Green Spaces? addresses our wider concerns.
  5. SNCIs are currently given protection from development under SADMP DM19. This states that ‘Development which would have a harmful impact on the nature conservation value of a Site of Nature Conservation Interest will not be permitted’. It is proposed that DM19 will be removed in its entirety. Under proposed new policy BG2: Nature conservation and recovery, this protection has been changed to read: ‘Development which would have a significantly harmful impact on local wildlife and geological sites, comprising Sites of Nature Conservation Interest (SNCIs) and Regionally Important Geological Sites (RIGS) as shown on the Policies Map, will not be permitted.’ This is a dilution of the current protection enjoyed by SNCIs (and RIGS); the phrase ‘significantly harmful’ is a subjective judgement and undermines the current protection provided, especially when the Chief Planning Officer has recently advised Councillors that damage to an SNCI which is offset by onsite mitigations under the Biodiversity Metric is not harm.
  6. Whilst we are very pleased to see that our campaign to have all those Sites of Nature Conservation Interest (SNCIs) which were allocated for development in 2014 (save for BSA1305 – why?) has succeeded and have had their Site Allocations removed, we are concerned to note that not all of the 108 sites (not 85 as is wrongly suggested) have also been designated as LGS – some are ROS and some have no designation at all. No explanation has been given for this.
  7. No schedule of the sites identified in BG2 has been produced. As we have pointed out, there are 108 SNCIs, not the 85 stated in Appendix 1: Sustainability Appraisal Updated Scoping Report 2023 A1-4 (at page 26). A schedule of all these sites will enable consultees to identify and locate them.
  8. In September 2021 the council unanimously resolved to protect the Green Belt and Bristol’s green spaces. Despite this, around 30 of the 96 sites proposed for residential development are green spaces (nearly 40 hectares) and three areas in our urban Green Belt are proposed to be removed from the Green Belt for development. No new green or open spaces are proposed.
  9. Proposed policy BG4: Trees is deeply flawed. As currently drafted it will allow developers to offset tree losses by using habitats that are not allowed under BNG 4.0. If allowed this will result in the hollowing out of Bristol’s trees and frustrate the One City plan to increase tree canopy (see Annex A below).
  10. The proposal that replacement trees ‘should be located as close as possible to the development site’ will still allow developers remove trees to build, because all they need to do is pay compensation for their replacement with no concern for where they are to be planted. This will result in trees and their biodiversity being lost from those areas under greatest development pressure, with any offsite compensation being exported to already green suburbs and creating even greater tree inequalities.
  11. It is proposed that development which would result in the loss of ancient woodland, or ancient or veteran trees, will not be permitted, but neither Bristol’s known veteran trees nor its 11 ancient woodlands are mapped or expressly protected on the Bristol Local Plan Policies Map.
  12. No express protection is given for other urban woodlands that are not ancient (woods that have not existed continuously since 1600), are not in a conservation area or are not protected with a TPO.

Our request

Bristol City Council has recently declared both Climate and Ecological Emergencies and resolved to protect our green spaces. The Environment Act 2021 with its still-to-be-published regulations (which will be fully implemented in 2024 together with a proposed new version of the National Planning Policy Framework) will provide even greater environmental protections and the next iteration of the One City Plan aspires to achieve a significant increase of tree canopy. Yet, against all this, the proposed new Local Plan will result in reduced protection for the environment when compared with the current, adopted Local Plan.

In light of this, we ask you to reject the Mayor’s recommendation until the above crucial issues have been addressed and insist that Bristol’s nature does not continue to suffer yet more decades of decline but is properly protected.

The Bristol Tree Forum

24 October 2023

Annex A – Email to BCC Specialist Planning Policy Officer 21 October 2023

Dear Michael,

I see that the latest iteration of the proposed Local Plan has been published. We are examining it and will comment in due course, but we have to express serious concerns about the proposed new wording of Policy BG4: Trees. 

We are disappointed that our proposal for BTRS has not been adopted, but we are also very concerned that this paragraph in particular, will provide developers with an opportunity to avoid replacing lost trees at all: ‘Where the tree compensation standard is not already met in full by biodiversity net gain requirements (policy BG3 ‘Achieving biodiversity gains’), for instance because biodiversity net gain requirements do not apply to the development or because biodiversity gains are provided through a different habitat type, development will still be expected to meet the tree compensation standard on-site or off-site through an appropriate legal agreement.‘

As you know, most trees in an urban environment will be classified as broad Individual tree habitat under BNG 4.0. This broad habitat has only two sub-types – rural and urban – and can only be replaced with the same broad habitat type (Individual tree) or by a more distinctive, High or Very High habitat. This means that other Medium (e.g. most woodland habitats) or Low distinctiveness habitats cannot be used without breaking the BNG 4.0 trading rules – as BG4 currently suggests it can. These High or Very High distinctiveness habitat types are rare, especially in the urban space. 

In this case, developers (who will not have the space to create all the Individual tree habitat that BNG 4.0 will demand**) will offer these or Individual tree habitats elsewhere and, because there are no such sites in Bristol, will offset the BNG losses out of the city, resulting in the hollowing out of Bristol’s trees and frustrating the One City plan to increase tree canopy.

We suggest that the proposed wording could also make BG4 unworkable because it is contrary to the BNG 4.0 rules and guidance. We suggest that you delete the words ‘or because biodiversity gains are provided through a different habitat type.’

Can you clarify whether the current Bristol Tree Replacement Standard SPD will remain, please. Is there a list of proposed deprecated policies and SPDs etc. available?

** For example, one small single dwelling development we are looking at which would require five BTRS trees to be planted to replace the three lost, will require 148 BNG 4.0 Small category trees to be planted to achieve a net gain of just 10%. There is not enough room on the site to plant the five BTRS trees, let alone 148.


Subsequent email to BCC Local Plan Team Manager 26 October 2023

Dear Colin,

I am sure you have seen our request to councillors in advance of next week’s Extraordinary Full Council meeting to adopt the Mayor’s recommendation to allow the draft Local Plan to progress to Regulation 19/20 consultation and then to independent examination. If not, I attach a copy.

We Bristolians are as much entitled to know which of their places (and a Local Plan is surely all about place) will not be protected under a new Local Plan as they are to know which will be. Yet, as far as we can see, this information has not been published with the papers laid before Councillors. Please correct me if I am wrong.

For example, we are aware that, under the 2019 document, New Protection for Open Space, it was proposed that Important Open Spaces, currently protected under SADMP DM17, would be replaced with new policies for Local Green Space (LGS) and Reserved Open Space (ROS) (para 2.13). It was obvious then that this would result in a large number of sites, currently protected under this part of DM17, losing this protection because they were not going to be designated as either LGS or ROS nor given any other protections. You will recall that it took us quite some time to get a list of these deprecated sites which we then listed in Appendix A of our response to that consultation. We have no idea whether our representations were considered. From what we have seen, it appears that, if they were, then they were ignored.

It also appears that those other places also given protection under DM17 – Unidentified Open Spacesand Urban landscapes – will also no longer be protected under the new plan, though this has not been expressly stated as far as we can see. It may well be that other place protections have also been quietly dropped and not replaced, but we cannot tell.
This is why we are calling for the following schedules (preferably geolocated) to be published before the next stage of the consultation begins:

  1. All proposed LGS/ROS designations.
  2. All sites (places) currently protected under the adopted Local Plan and how they will be protected (or not) under the new LP.
  3. Currently adopted policies which will be removed – Core, Site Allocation and Development Management Policies (SADMP) and ancillarySupplementary Planning Documents (SPDs) etc. – cross-tabulated to show which of these policies have been transferred to the proposed LP and which have not.
  4. All sites proposed to be protected under BG2.
  5. All known veteran and ancient trees and woodland within the city boundaries.

If this information is not provided then it will be impossible for those who wish to respond to the consultation to make an informed decision whether or not to accept what is being proposed and the whole consultation process will, we suggest, be fatally flawed.

I have also heard it suggested that, should Councillors not approve the Mayor’s recommendation then the current adopted Local Plan will lapse and allow developers to proceed as they wish. You know as well as I do that this is not correct. It may well be that, on appeal, developers may argue that Paragraph 11d of the NPPF applies because the Local Plan is out-of-date (Homes England argued this in the recent Brislington Meadows appeal), but this is a very different matter from what I understand has been suggested. Hopefully you will ensure that Councillors are not misled if this is repeated.

I look forward to hearing from you.


[1] R v North & East Devon Health Authority, ex parte Coughlan [2001] QB  213, [2000] 3 All ER 850, 97 LGR 703

The vital role of trees in urban development

There’s a climate emergency and we need to act. With higher temperatures and more severe weather events than just a decade ago, we must take action at the local as well as the global level.

Bristol City Council declared a Climate Emergency in 2018, reflecting the need to reduce the city’s contribution to the causes of climate change, and to adapt and be resilient to further expected climate impacts. For the declaration to be meaningful, it has to result in practical changes, for example the protection of existing trees on development sites. With important urban trees being routinely felled, there is no evidence that this is the case. If Bristol continues in this way, the city will become unliveable in the climate crisis.

The Council is now drafting a tree strategy for the city, which we hope will become a key element of the forthcoming revised Local Plan. We hope that the strategy will protect existing trees and prioritise the planting of replacement and new trees across the city. We have asked for 18 principles to be included in the strategy.

If our urban environment is going to be liveable in the long term, we need to create new developments that can cope with the changes in the local climate expected in the future. The benefits of trees in the fight against climate change are now well understood: trees lock up carbon, reducing pollution and flooding. They are also the best way of reducing the urban heat island effect, decreasing the temperatures of heatwaves by up to 10°C . It’s therefore vital that green infrastructure forms part of any proposed development. This is particularly crucial in the city centre.

On every occasion that trees are felled, we’re told it will be all right, as they will be replaced. Often these replacement trees are never planted because there is nowhere to plant them, or if planted, they die and are not replaced. At any rate, we need tree canopy and shade now, not in 50 years’ time when any new trees that might survive will replace the canopy lost. This is why we must protect existing trees, and if trees must be lost, local tree replacements must be planted and not just promised.

A warmer climate increases the risk of overheating and heat-related illness, even death. In the heat wave of 2003, around 70,000 people died across Europe due to the extreme heat, with older people and children particularly vulnerable. However, we can reduce much of the risk without the need for active cooling, by incorporating effective measures into development proposals from the earliest design stage. New buildings and external spaces must be designed to provide year-round comfort and support well-being. On-site tree planting for shade will contribute to this by minimising the amount of heat entering buildings. All new developments will be expected to demonstrate through ‘sustainability statements’ how they would incorporate such measures into their design from the outset.

How green (and blue) infrastructure reduces climate impacts

Developers must take into account that changes in the local climate are likely to: increase flood risk and water stress; change the shrink-swell characteristics of clay soils affecting foundations and pipework; affect slope stability; and affect the durability of building materials. Incorporating green and blue infrastructure, such as trees and water features, in developments will help to reduce all these effects. Green and blue infrastructure should be multifunctional, that is, provide ecology and biodiversity benefits as well as climate adaptation in developments. Where appropriate, this should include the use of living roofs with a sufficient substrate depth to maximise cooling benefits. However, the cooling effect of green roofs is a fraction of that afforded by trees.

Long-term thinking

As we build more homes, businesses and communities, it’s essential that we retain and integrate important existing trees within any new development. We must also consider carefully the size, species and placement of new trees provided as part of any planned landscape treatment, for example in terms of:

  • ensuring that any new streets are tree-lined
  • focusing once again on large-form trees that will be long-lived and provide substantial shade, rather than small, short-lived trees such as Rowan or Amelanchier
  • reducing or mitigating run-off and flood risk on the site
  • increasing on-site canopy cover and providing shade and shelter
  • ensuring that newly planted trees will be maintained in the long term and replaced if necessary.

Where tree loss or damage is unavoidable, and not merely expedient, within a development site, new replacement trees of an appropriate species must be provided either on or off site and their long-term management and maintenance secured.


We have submitted our proposals for how trees lost to development should be replaced as for of the Local Plan Review – Our proposal for a new Bristol Tree Replacement Standard using Biodiversity Metric 4.0